Demolition without consent – again.

This is getting to be a habit – shop fronts and buildings being demolished without  consent from Redbridge council.

On May Day bank holiday in 2009, 46-48 High Street was torn down. That year also saw the shop front at no.62 completely removed and replaced. Last year, no.1 High Street was demolished. Wanstead Elecrical Appliances is another shop front that was put in without consent a few years ago. Now there’s some builders next door at no.21.

After alerting the planning department that work had started on this building, it took 11 days before the site was visited by a planning investigator, Mark Broad. Here is an update from him:

The property is currently undergoing building work to make the structure safe and last Friday the steel case protecting the roller shutter was removed from the front of the property as this had caused a major crack to appear on the internal walls. The front of the property is currently leaning forward onto the High Street and therefore the scaffolding has been erected to secure the front of the property.

The owners have been advised that they do not have the benefit of conservation area consent in relation to any demolition of the building. I will continue to monitor the situation and will update you again in the near future.”

So, the owner will need to apply for demolition consent, and also conservation area consent for a new shop front. Let’s keep our eyes peeled for that.

The British Heart Foundation can make their shops look nice – when they want to

Further to my post on the British Heart Foundation, I have just found this photo of a rather nice looking British Heart Foundation shop. It is on their property management company’s website.

See how their shop front design has been adapted. The colour red is muted, the type is much smaller and raised – and in red and blue instead of white. It looks individual, and yet still carries the same brand authority.

Why can’t the same amount of thought and consideration go into applications for Wanstead?

You can comment on the proposal on the Redbridge website. Search for planning reference 0155/11 – click on the link “comment on this application”.

Bennett’s newsagents

The Smarter High Street Campaign is working with Bennetts Newsagents on their planned shop front revamp.

The arrival of Tesco has meant a complete re-appraisal of the business for Ronnie, who has owned the shop for twenty years.

Newsagent shop frontBennetts has the best read noticeboard in town, so this will stay. However, we can expect to see a much more inviting and smarter shop front, with an independent feel to it. But the cosmetic changes are only the half of it.

Ronnie may well be branching out into new areas of stock. With the large premises that Ronnie has, there is so much scope. A bigger and better stationery department? Perhaps. Computer supplies? Maybe.

What would you like to see on offer at Bennetts? Please let us know – leave your comments below.

Heart in the right place?

The British Heart Foundation is coming to Wanstead. And here’s a sketch of how it will look, if the shop front design gets approved by Redbridge.

This is a mock up using the actual plans, to scale.

Charity shops are a great thing, but that doesn’t mean we should get lumbered with a standard, non-conservation area shop front. This shop design does nothing to enhance or protect the character of Wanstead high street. It dominates the street scene at the expense of the surrounding independent shops.

A simple modification of type scale and muting the show-stopping red would go a long way. Also, raised lettering gives a noticeable touch of elegance. Here’s how that might look.

A more sympathetic look for Wanstead

Boots, Tesco and the Co-op are already dominating the street scene  and giving Wanstead High Street a generic look. Wanstead deserves better.

You can help make a difference. View the plans and leave your comments, positive or negative, for the planning committee to take into consideration. Search for planning reference 0155/11 – click on the link “comment on this application”.

Letting signs will be tackled, say planning officers

As reported in the Guardian, I toured the high street on 17th February with two chief planning officers from Redbridge. It was a first time experience for Alan Romain, Head of Enforcement.

Countrywide Commercial letting sign

We focused on the proliferation of letting agent boards and illuminated signs. Letting boards are covered by local authority planning regulations – however, these aren’t available on the Redbridge website. It’s impossible for us to report a breach of these regulations if we don’t know what they are. I’m particularly interested to know if the letting sign above OneDeko falls within the regulations – it is absolutely HUGE.

What I did find out from Alan Romain is that they must be removed no later than 14 days after completion of sale or granting of tenancy. Mr Romain made a list of all the letting boards in the high street and will be chasing up the property agents concerned.

Massive sign above OneDeko

After doing a bit of research, it seems there is something more that Redbridge could do reduce the problem of letting boards. Councils can apply to the Secretary of State for a Regulation 7 Direction – this removes the ‘deemed consent’ applied to letting signs, meaning that all letting signs require planning permission – which would give us a chance to comment on each application.

Aside from letting boards, the officers catalogued dilapidations, construction advertisements, satellite dishes and illuminations. I can’t help but feel that with a planning department that is already short staffed, heads of departments working part time and the impending council cuts, progress will be difficult.

One thing that both officers explicitly promised, was the removal of the torn and tattered plastic awnings over the windows of the tuition centre above Boots. Let’s see what happens.

An example from Westminster council (click to enlarge)

Standard guidelines for the display of letting/for sale boards

  • The board should be no bigger than 2 square metres, but if two boards are joined together to form a single advertisement, a total surface area of 2.3 square metres is permitted.
  • For residential for sale and let boards the board must not exceed 0.5 of a square metre, or a total area of 0.6 of a square metre for two joined boards.
  • You may only display ONE board on the premises (or two joined to form a “V” as mentioned above).
  • No advertisement board is allowed to extend outwards from the wall of a building by more than 1 metre.
  • The board must not be illuminated in any circumstances.
  • The board must not have the highest part of the advertisement at more than 4.6 metres above ground-level, or 3.6 metres in any Area of Special Control (except where advertising a sale or letting of premises situated in a building above these specified height limits).
  • The board must be removed not later than 14 days after completion of the sale or granting of the tenancy.

All outdoor advertisements must also comply with five ‘standard conditions’.

They must:

  1. Be kept clean and tidy.
  2. Be kept in a safe condition.
  3. Have the permission of the owner of the site on which they are displayed (this includes the Highway Authority if the sign is to be placed on highway land).
  4. Not obscure, or hinder the interpretation of, official road, rail, waterway or aircraft signs, or otherwise make hazardous the use of these types of transport.
  5. Be removed carefully where so required by the planning authority.

High Street happenings

Oxfam social

Local Oxfam supporters will be hosting a party at the Oxfam bookshop on Wanstead High Street from 7pm on Wednesday 9th March.
This is an opportunity for the local community to come together over tea and cakes, socialise with friends and chat informally with Oxfam representatives who will be there to tell you about their projects and the role you could play in their work. It coincides with Oxfam’s nationwide celebration of International Women’s Day.

Everyone is welcome. This is exactly the kind of event that encourages a sense of community in our high streets.

Snips and snails, and puppy dogs tails

Knock Down Ginger boutique opens a children’s hair parlour on Saturday 5th March.

A hair cut can be a traumatic experience for little ones, and it’s not easy for parents to find an experienced ‘child friendly’ salon. So Rina Henry has integrated a parlour where children and toddlers can have an anxiety-free experience – in a fun, child friendly atmosphere.

Book and appointment for 5th or 6th March and it will be half price. Call 0208 530 7646.

In the meantime enjoy this little video of Rina’s delightful shop.

Walk this way: enforcement officer will tour Wanstead High Street

Two of Redbridge’s top planning officers have agreed to give more attention to Wanstead High Street.

Above One Deco: lease sign hangs over pedestrians. Alan Romain has offered to tackle all the letting agent signs.

Murray Broad, Head of Development Control and Alan Romain, Head of Enforcement, listened to the concerns of the Wanstead Society at its committee meeting last Wednesday. As a result, Alan Romain will be doing his FIRST EVER walk down our High Street on the 17th February. He’ll be noting unwanted developments, specifically targeting the letting boards which have become a blight over recent years.

There has been frustration as The Wanstead Society has tried to protect the character of the High Street with no results from Redbridge. In the meeting I pointed out that in the last 7 years, not one single enforcement case in the High Street has produced a satisfactory outcome. Shop fronts have been ripped out, buildings have been demolished, windows have been replaced, unsuitable signs have been put up, shutters have appeared – none of which have been reversed or amended.

Alan Romain has worked for Redbridge since the 1980s. In 2008, his department had 1,219 enforcement cases – an untenable situation. The planning chief set him a target of reducing it to 500 in the space of a year. It’s a known fact that when staff are given targets, they will adopt creative (some would say cunning) tactics to meet them. So in 2008-2009 cases of unwanted PVC windows were dropped, as were others like Wanstead Electrical Appliances – where the shop front was ripped out without permission.

We hope that once Alan sees the High Street for himself, he will galvanise his team into action and start giving Wanstead the attention it deserves.

Cuckfield House – first impressions count

The proposed signage

After my posting on the proposed signage for Cuckfield House, Gini Bhogal has decided to modify her plans.

I visited Gini yesterday. It was kind of her to take time out of what was going to be a hectic day – the day of her launch party. A special marquee was ready and waiting for her eager guests.

After spending a lot of time, money and effort on the styling of this business, coming up against any kind of criticism must have been difficult. However, Gini took the comments on board with good grace. She agreed that the building would look better without the high level sign on the brickwork.

This is great news.

Gini grew up around some lovely towns in Kent like Rochester and so appreciates places with charm and characterful architecture. And that’s what attracted her to Wanstead. Many years ago, Gini put her big wish down on paper – which was to open her own salon in Wanstead. And here she is!

Luckily, one of her members of staff is also a graphic designer. The logo was beautifully crafted by Nim Sira – great care was taken over the typography.

But here we see what can happen when you hand things over to a signmaker. The common-or-garden signmaker may not be a trained designer – it’s like asking a brick layer to design you a house. My advice to anyone starting a shop would be to get an experienced designer to visualise the signs in-situ before briefing the signmaker – especially if you intend using expensive materials.

We wish Gini and her team the best of luck.

The conservation area needs pointing out

One of the simplest yet most effective things that Redbridge could do to help protect the character of Wanstead is to install a sign saying “CONSERVATION AREA”.

There is a lack of awareness which I’ve witnessed during conversations with shop owners and staff. The presence of signage would put out the general message that ‘we care about the character of our high street’. The perception is, that we don’t.

Places like Croydon have conservation area awareness built into their road signs.

Installing signs would be a preventative measure. Instead, Redbridge planners are swamped with enforcement cases which they simply can’t deal with.

There has been an ongoing quest for conservation area signage since 2003. Numerous requests in writing and in person have been put forward to various council officers and councillors over the years – including the Chief Planning Officer, Chris Berry. At the Wanstead Society AGM Councillor Sue Nolan agreed to start the ball rolling.

To date, nothing has happened.

In the last couple of months, we’ve seen five cases of internally illuminated shop signs which have been installed without permission. This literally snowballed after one was installed without permission at Elegance Dry Cleaners. It seems other shops have simply followed suit.

Awareness of Conservation Area guidelines will save the thousands being spent on enforcement cases and legal fees, and help us keep Wanstead special.

Will Cuckfield House be beautiful?

The renovated Cuckfield Garage

Is there room for another beauty business in Wanstead? Another two have sprung up recently – so, with all the competition around, who is likely to stand out?

Gini Bhogal opens on valentines day at Cuckfield House – the renovated Cuckfield Garage – and they’ve applied for permission for signage. Planning application no. 2850/10 is for acrylic and vinly signs with lighting and it’s currently being considered by Redbridge (click here to download the drawings).

Gini Bhogal already has a stylish logo – using a glamorous 1930s typeface and a charming fairy silhouette. But the signage is doing the logo, and therefore the business, an injustice. The owners have looked at maximising the size of the logo without considering the building design or proportions. The existing, integral fascia has been sidelined and a large, shiny acrylic(!) board added above it.

Computer generated mock-up: The proposed signage – an acrylic board at high level.

“Beautyjustaroundthecorner.com” is quite hard to read, and it has been repeated in close proximity, which creates too much ‘noise’.

The following image is a mock-up of how the space could be used in a better way, using the existing fascia and making use of the space above it.

Computer generated mock-up: Less is more. Which salon would you rather visit?

This design uses raised lettering, with an elegant cut-out of the fairy perched in the space above. The web address has been given a typographical treatment to increase legibility.

Making the web address a bit more readable.

This is just a suggestion, and we welcome your feedback. Which design do you prefer, and why?